AMERICAN FOOTBALL ASSOCIATION 2005 HALL OF FAME
| NAME | HOMETOWN | CATEGORY | SPONSOR |
| Ron Anton | Rochester, Wisconsin | Player | Bob Milkie |
| Dick Attreau | Oak Lawn, Illinois | Player | Bob Webb |
| Paul 'Rock' Carter | Bloomfield, Indiana | Player | James Stamper |
| Tim Colton | Milton, Massachusetts | Player | Larry DeVoe |
| Terry Converse | Racine, Wisconsin | Player | Joe Mooney |
| Bernard Bun Cronin* | Hudson Falls, New York | Official | Mike Cronin |
| Steve Ellis | Brooklyn, New York | Executive | AFA Alumni |
| Troy Faunce | Algonquin, Illinois | Player | Eliseo Saldivar |
| Terry Fernandez | Casselberry, Florida | Player | Tom Bland |
| Alex Flores | San Jose, California | Executive | AFA Alumni |
| Bob Floyd | Lynchburg, Virginia | Official | Hal Lockhart |
| Greg Fohrman* | Sleepy Hollow, Illinois | Youth | AFA Alumni |
| Mike Frazier | Suawanee, Georgia | Executive | AFA Alumni |
| Kenneth Glenn | Garfield Hts., Ohio | Player | Richard Dial |
| Brad Haydu | Aldergrove, Canada | Player | ‘Moose’ Fahey |
| Norris Jackson | Detroit, Michigan | Coach | AFA Alumni |
| Mike Jennings | Hazel Crest, Illinois | Player | Marc May |
| Edward Jordan | Joliet, Illinois | Player | Force Alumni |
| Cheryl Kardas | Removille, Illinois | Executive | Jim Nugent |
| Al Klaeren | Elmhurst, Illinois | Player | Travelers Alumni |
| Gary Kuykendall | Chicago, Illinois | Player | Charlie Bliss |
| Mike Lentz | Brewerton, New York | Coach | Dick Leland |
| Norm Nissen | Bloomingdale, Illinois | Player | Roman Strzala |
| Pat Nulty | Graham , NC | Player | George Ashcraft |
| John Otterman | Akron, Ohio | Player | John Tichy |
| Paul Pisellini | Elmhurst, Illinois | Executive | Paul Whiteside |
| Ray Powell | Arlington, Texas | Player | Bob Blechen |
| Dick Promer | Kaukauna, Wisconsin | Player | Doug Brozek |
| Dave Rice | Marco Island, Florida | Executive | Ron Real |
| Jim Righeimer | Lincolnshire, Illinois | Official | Jack Pittges |
| Larry Rydbon | Chambersburg, Penn. | Player | Dave Bonsell |
| Ed Schemski, Jr. | Tinley Park, Illinois | Player | Basile/Grohn |
| Pat Sharpe | West Dundee, Illinois | Executive | Eliseo Saldivar |
| Jerry Tadych | Manitowoc, Wisconsin | Player | Harold Hrberman |
| Doug Tibbitts | Marne, Michigan | Coach | Greg Skowronski |
| Dan Van Holt | New Port Richey, FL | Player | Mike Norvickas |
| Mike Willkomm | Pleasant Prairie, WI | Player | Philip Miceck |
| Gary Williams | Allison Park, PA | Player | Tom Averell |
| Bob Yurachek | Chester, Virginia | Player | Mary Lockhart |