Elements and Considerations of a Successful Disaster Preparedness Supplemental Communications Plan using the Personal Radio Services Including GMRS, FRS, MURS, and CB

 

(This is a work in progress. PRA invites comments.

Send those comments to doug@praweb.org)

 

Purpose

 

This document is intended to be a bullet-point resource and reference for persons, organizations, and OEMs interested in developing community communications programs that use the Family Radio Service, General Mobile Radio Service, Citizens Radio Service, and Multi-Use Radio Service.

 

Set Expectations

 

People need to know what to expect. This is the most overlooked aspect of many service related businesses and is no less important in emergency management. When people do not know what to expect they get angry, lose focus, and pandemonium results. In the case of a disaster, panic prevails over common sense. We cannot let that happen in our communities.

 

Likewise we CANNOT create expectations that are impossible to meet.  There are efforts to declare Family Radio Service Channel one as an emergency channel that any citizen can use to call for help after an emergency has occurred. The proposal claims it is “instant, reliable crisis communications,” but this is far from the truth. Such a plan is unmanageable in its scope, particularly when no neighborhood familiarization or training is even suggested and in fact declared by the major proponent as unnecessary!

 

Planners need to provide the general public with some idea of the “who, what, when, where, why and how” behind the mitigation efforts for the aftermath of a disaster. Planners need to do this before the disaster and NOT after the disaster! It should be an aggressive effort of the utmost importance. One way to accomplish this is to engage the public in disaster planning at the grass-roots-neighborhood level. (CERT, neighborhood associations, Neighborhood Watch, local public meetings, REACT, building associations, parks and recreation meetings, public awareness advertising on radio and television etc.)

 

The public must accept a level of a responsibility toward disaster preparation in order to understand their role in disaster recovery. Setting expectations means the public learns basic concepts and can keep those concepts in mind so that clear thinking prevails over panic thinking.

 

 

The following are some expectations to take into consideration for a communications plan using the various Personal Radio Services.

 

 

  1. The Federal Communications Commission Rules and Regulations must be followed in every case. Licenses must be obtained where necessary and all users should be familiar with Part 95 of the FCC Rules as they pertain to GMRS and to the unlicensed FRS also in Part 95. The same goes for other radio services in use like Amateur Radio, FCC R&R Part 97, CB Radio Service Part 95, and the Business Radio Services in Part 90.
  2. Neighbors must plan to be without emergency services for up to seventy-two hours or more after a disaster. (More or less depending on the severity and scope of the event.) Every jurisdiction has a policy regarding the delivery of services after a disaster. It needs to be explained. People’s expectations must be set.
  3. Emergency OES/OEM officials need to explain the expected role FRS and GMRS (Personal Radio Services) have in the event of a disaster. What it can and cannot do and what it is expected to do, how it can be used, how it should not be used.
  4. Any use of disaster related supplemental two-way radio to relay information to public safety officials must be planned for and tested ahead of time. There must be alternate plans e.g. a Plan B.
  5. Possession and use of an FRS or GMRS two-way radio does not guarantee an instant and reliable or an immediate and effective response to an individual’s call for help using that radio. NEVER set the expectation that calling out on a two-way radio will guarantee a response. Unfortunately, since this concept has already been heavily publicized some families may already believe it is a done deal. OEM’s need to reach these families before the next disaster.
  6. Whenever possible, use cellular or land-line telephones instead of two-way radios. Conventional methods of communication (communication systems the public is already familiar with) should always be the preferred method of communication. It is recognized that these systems may be down or temporarily unavailable immediately after a disaster event. It is the time period immediately after the event and just before these systems are restored that very-local neighborhood two-way radio communication can be of the greatest help in mitigating welfare checks and rescues.
  7. Two-way radios are primarily for neighbors to communicate with each other during and after a disaster so that CERT volunteers or others can provide immediate search and rescue or so neighbors can assist each other.
  8. Two-way radio users must learn how to use their radios properly. They should know how to turn it on and off, how to change channels, disable coded squelch tones, adjust the volume, and transmit.
  9. Emergency aid may not be available to some people whether or not they have a radio. They may be isolated due to impassable conditions, flooding, down power lines, fire, fallen structures, blocked roads, or there may not be public safety or other resources to assist them.
  10. While it cannot be guaranteed, having a two-way radio may enable appropriate officials to communicate with persons in isolated areas.
  11. Emergency management leaders, CERT trainers, and hobby radio operators need to train their neighbors in the use of two-way radios.
  12. Persons should be expected to obey emergency management officials and LEAVE potential disaster areas before the event! When you are asked or ordered to leave a potential disaster area LEAVE! If you cannot leave on your own seek assistance but leave! Do not stick around expecting to use your tiny little FRS radio to call for help if you find yourself in deep water!
  13. Since we generally have a very good understanding of what can occur in a natural disaster in the United States every person should plan accordingly. Offices of OES and OEM have pamphlets and websites persons can visit for disaster planning information.
  14. The laws of physics as those laws relate to radio propagation of UHF radio waves apply to the eventual range of a radio in a given circumstance. The laws of sales and marketing do not apply.
  15. Amateur Radio operators are NOT allowed to transmit on GMRS in an emergency with modified equipment on GMRS. (Or with Part 95 approved equipment.) Amateur Radio operators do NOT have GMRS privileges at any time.
  16. The public must understand the procedures and reasons for evacuation and NOT ignore evacuation warnings.

 

 

Questions to Ask before you Begin Planning

 

  1. How far will you need to communicate?
  2. Do you need a relay by radio or telephone?
  3. Who, what, where are your relay resources?
  4. How many people and which people will have radios? (Not every person in a large apartment building needs a radio.)
  5. Do you have alternates for your Block Captains? (Or whatever you call your very-local neighborhood emergency coordinators.)
  6. What kind of interference may already exist on FRS and GMRS in my area?
  7. Can the interference be mitigated?
  8. What is the likelihood of intentional interference and how will interference be dealt with it if it happens?
  9. Which radio channels shall we use for our neighborhood? Select based on current use. Scan the FRS and GMRS channels. Monitor activity. Choose the quietest frequencies for your area. GMRS repeater output channels may be busy with higher powered radio stations. Very-local communications should use FRS one-fourteen.
  10. Are GMRS repeaters available? Where are they? Who is already using them? Can your neighborhood benefit from using the repeaters?
  11. Have the licensees of those GMRS repeaters, or have other GMRS licensees been asked to join the neighborhood team? Remember GMRS repeaters are private property. While most licensees will be happy to participate as part of a local communications plan they are NOT required to do so. AT this FCC database you can search for GMRS licensees in your zip code: http://wireless2.fcc.gov/UlsApp/UlsSearch/searchGmrs.jsp
  12. Does your local repeater have a tone for the neighborhood? (CTCSS/DCS)
  13. How far away are we from the main roads?
  14. Will our radios reach from our residences to key neighborhood access points? Have we tested our neighborhood network?
  15. Can we communicate with other neighborhoods? Do we need to?
  16. Is there a way to relay requests for help beyond the range of FRS? Beyond the range of GMRS?
  17. Are there critical services, plants, roads, etc in the neighborhood where we should put someone with a radio? Water pumping plant, club houses, damns, beaches, guard shacks, major intersections etc.
  18. Are we prepared to direct public safety resources to rescues and medical emergencies after a disaster? How can we use our radios to do this?
  19. Do we have a GMRS licensee in my neighborhood? Is that licensee part of our plan?
  20. Do we have an Amateur Radio operator in our neighborhood? Is that Ham part of our plan?
  21. Does or OEM office know about our group?
  22. Do our OEM and local public safety officials have a copy of our neighborhood communications plan?
  23. Has our OEM trained us on basic emergency planning?
  24. Do we have a neighborhood map and local telephone list? Is there an alerting calling-tree to alert neighbors to take cover?
  25. Do we have a welfare telephone calling-tree created to check on neighbors on a priority basis! Elderly first!
  26. Does our OEM have a CERT program? Do we have trained people in our neighborhood?
  27. Do we have a meeting place for training? Can we arrange one?
  28. Do we have meetings already scheduled so we can add this topic to the agenda?

 

 

 

Assumptions

 

  1. Many persons using FRS radios will have little or no prior communications training. They will have no confidence in the method or the device. Some may even refuse to own or learn to use one.
  2. Radios may prove completely frustrating to some folks and they will give up using them and resort to calling out for help. Planners should plan around both scenarios and NOT rely solely on two-way radios.
  3. Calling out for help, if within earshot of a neighbor, makes more sense than taking the time to find one’s radio. Neighbors in no immediate peril will exit their homes safely and begin checking on others.
  4. Some persons may have no or very limited experience with a two-way radio. Finding the push-to-talk function may be difficult for some.
  5. Some users of FRS and GMRS radios will panic and cause unwanted interference trying to reach anyone they can hear. They may even unwittingly interfere with rescues in progress.
  6. Some users of radios may be trapped in buildings or in other dangerous locations. It may be difficult to locate these people. Some very-local responders should be trained in simple radio direction finding techniques to approximate the location of trapped radio users. (Body fading.)
  7. CTCSS and DCS settings will prevent communication and cause severe confusion.
  8. Individuals with criminal intent may attempt to take advantage of persons in distress, or fake distress calls in order to identify the location of law enforcement or search and rescue resources or unprotected properties to coordinate looting.
  9. The lack of training and sophistication of users requires extraordinary personal communication and negotiation abilities of persons carrying radios and responding to victims. Some pre-disaster communications training is required.
  10. CB may be useless or of very limited range. Most CB’s will be in cars. There will be a few base stations. Communication during periods of active skip may be limited depending on local terrain.
  11. MURS users will be scarce.
  12. Many families will already own an FRS or a GMRS bubble-pack radio. Not everyone in the family will know how to use them. In most cases batteries will be dead or will soon be dead since most radios cannot be recharged in a vehicle.
  13. Some two-way radio users will not cooperate with neighborhood groups and will do as they please. Some may even cause deliberate interference.
  14. Some smaller groups will organize and use FRS and GMRS radios without being part of a larger plan. OEM officials will eventually learn about these groups and have difficulty verifying their authenticity.
  15. Local business radio users are going to be using their own business radio channels. OES OEM should coordinate with companies that have large fleets to take advantage of business repeaters and high powered simplex radios.

 

Planning

 

·        Participants using GMRS should license in GMRS. Planning should include local GMRS licensees. There should be an effort to license families in GMRS in America’s neighborhoods that want to help each other during or immediately after an emergency using two-way radios.

·        Encourage local jurisdictions to have an FRS GMRS communications plan within the existing FCC Rules governing both services. These jurisdictions should locate and negotiate with all GMRS resources.

·        GMRS based organizations can create a committee to explore the appropriate use of the FRS in an emergency for their area and make recommendations to OES/OEMs. GMRS groups should support community based disaster communication plans and work within those plans to provide public emergency communications. 

·        GMRS repeater owners should invite new families onto their systems so families get used to operating GMRS radio systems.

·        The public needs informative packets, and training information.    No disaster program will work without training.  This includes extremely basic radio operation instructions, storage of spare batteries, and disaster related supplies. Such training should be provided through local offices of emergency management or groups with CERT affiliations, Neighborhood Watch, community associations etc.

·        Eliminate any public expectation that FRS channel one can be used in any emergency to summon assistance on demand.

·        In a local plan make use of radio frequencies after surveying your area for activity. Create a primary and backup channel.

·        After an emergency, communications enthusiasts can use an ordinary radio scanner and scan all GMRS and FRS channels for any disoriented citizens.

·        It might be helpful to also scan and listen to activity on locally used business radio frequencies.

·        Know your neighbors ahead of time. Get to know folks on a first and last name basis before the disaster strikes.

·        Have designated alternates for important tasks.

·        Every family should have a communications plan for a disaster. This includes a telephone contact plan, family-expectation setting regarding future welfare related telephone calls. Every family should have one designated contact person far from the emergency (another city or state) that can be a single point of contact for all family members.

·        Disaster communications planners, while taking into consideration the limitations of GMRS and FRS should:

a.       Share with neighborhoods the benefits of communicating after an emergency to assess the welfare of persons by radio in a very local way.

b.      The need for a neighbor or neighbors to learn how to effectively use a two-way radio during and immediately after a disaster.

c.       Encourage neighbors to use radios with coded-squelch disabled.

d.      Develop local ways for neighborhoods to communicate with OES/OEM officials.

 

 

Suggestions

 

  1. A neighborhood should standardize on a particular make and model of FRS radio (if possible) for those people that have no prior experience using radios and that might be likely to have problems using their radios.
  2. Pick a radio that uses regular alkaline batteries you can replace. When electricity is out you may not be able to recharge your rechargeable batteries.
  3. Some simple method of wearing the radio on the belt, around the neck, or clipped to clothing should be devised so it is not lost. (Especially for the elderly and the sick.)
  4. Use of call tones should be discouraged. These tones serve no useful purpose. They make the radio an obnoxious toy.
  5. A neighborhood communications volunteer should set up FRS radios for those that cannot do it properly themselves.
  6. Neighborhoods should have Block Captains. Block Captains have the responsibility to call everyone on the radio during and after a disaster to verify the welfare of people in the homes and buildings around them.
  7. Large buildings should have designated Floor Captains and alternates that carry radios. Every building should have a communications plan in place with their evacuation plan. It is not realistic that every employee should carry an FRS radio in a business structure but key employees that are part of the neighborhood disaster plan should do so.
  8. A neighborhood’s radio system should be tested at least four times a year. A good time may be just prior to a Neighborhood Watch meeting or local disaster preparedness meeting. Neighbors should use their radios informally all year so they become familiar with the radio.
  9. As many volunteers as can be found should take CERT training so everyone responding to calls from help can so do with some confidence and without injury.
  10. CERT teams should not have to design or re-design communications systems or methods already included in their local disaster plans. CERT emphasis is on rescue and public welfare. Disaster planners should do this work for CERT volunteers.
  11. Neighbors who want to license in the GMRS should pay the license fee, and buy a base station and mobile radio capable of attaching to an external antenna. These neighbors can be a link to a designated resource up the communications chain.
  12. Amateur Radio operators in the neighborhood should be identified and included in neighborhood communications planning. Amateurs can serve as a neighborhood’s link back to the designated public safety agency. Areas with great distances between neighborhoods can benefit from such a scheme.
  13. A neighborhood should be included in a multi-hazard functional plan for the jurisdiction in which it is located. Contact persons, and their addresses and phone numbers should be kept up to date for every local neighborhood. This is easier to do through Neighborhood Watch or Neighborhood Association meetings since these are regularly conducted by local police jurisdictions.
  14. When using a radio to talk to a neighbor use plain language. Do not use ten codes.
  15.  Use radio codes instead of plain language only if you can guarantee there will be no misunderstandings.
  16. Maritime communities should think about communicating with each other on GMRS and FRS. VHF maritime channels cannot be legally used on land. The maritime channels may be busy with maritime distress activities.
  17. Teach everyone who owns a radio how to use the radio with specific emphasis on:
    1. Listening before transmitting
    2. Disabling CTCSS and DCS
    3. Disabling scrambling
    4. Speaking in plain language.
    5. Directing all communications to a specific person or unit.
    6. Responding only to known persons.
    7. How to make a general call to anyone that can hear you only when you cannot reach designated persons.
    8. Having enough batteries on hand to use your radio continuously for at least seventy-two hours.
    9. Keeping your radio and batteries within easy to reach, away from areas that might be damaged during earthquakes or storms.
    10. In advance warning of an emergency putting your radio on your belt or clipping it to your clothing.
    11. Putting packs of extra batteries in your pocket in case you are not able to get back to your supply in the event of a building collapse.
    12. In advance of a disaster warning, attempt to contact other members of your neighborhood group and check in with Block Captains. Block Captains should have paper and pencil to record names and addresses of check-ins. It is also good to know who has already evacuated.
    13. Have a current neighborhood map with address numbers, telephone numbers, and names of families recorded on the map.
    14. After a disaster Block Captains should contact every person that checked in and attempt to contact those that did not.
    15. Block Captains should allow persons in actual distress to check in before those that are not. Everyone needs to know they are helped by neighborhood resources on a priority basis!
    16. Persons in distress should begin transmitting the moment they determine their vocal cries for help are not being heard. Transmit and listen, transmit and listen. “This is Bill on Main St. Please help me.” Stop transmitting when you are called or are asked to do so. Indicate you are injured when you are called. State your name, last known location (where you should be), and the nature of your emergency.  (A suggested communications protocol need to be developed. (This is similar to the suggested methods of calling and speaking with a Police, Fire, or Medical dispatch center using 911.)
    17. Signaling in the event you cannot speak. Radios require speech, but you can create a method of signaling, or responding to yes and no questions if you can tap or rub the radio against a solid object while transmitting. Whatever system you develop should be widely understood among the neighbors and only used as a last resort.
    18. Preventing an open-microphone condition and what to do if one happens e.g. switching to an alternate channel.

 

 

OES/OEM’s, Public Safety - Make a Commitment Now

 

There are some considerations in this list that are frankly, a little outside the scope of FRS and GMRS but these should be considered so that FRS and GMRS use can be considered in context by disaster planners.

 

 

 

A Quick Look at the Personal Radio Services

 

Citizens Radio Service

 

Multi-Use Radio Service

 

 

 

Family Radio Service

 

 

 

General Mobile Radio Service

 

 

 

Methods of Communication for Very-local Communication (Under development)

 

The following suggestions are for very-local neighborhood groups. Your implementation may vary depending upon colloquial circumstances. This is not a one-size fits all approach.

 

 

 

Mistakes to Avoid

 

 

 

Opportunities for Manufacturers

 

Manufacturers have gone about the development and marketing of FRS radios in all the wrong ways. Development is entirely about what the marketing manager expects will tempt the average citizen to buy the product without regard to licensing. The marketers want the radios loaded with features. They insist on making bizarre claims as to the range radios will transmit effectively.  It is all about what a marketing manager believes will sell the product and not at all about how useful the radio actually is. The most glaring examples are the intentional built-in complexities of these radios that should be so incredibly simple. Set-up menus and multiple controls confuse and bemuse the average citizen making the radios almost impossible to use. One excellent argument against the use of today’s FRS/GMRS bubble-pack radios for use in emergency situations was put this way:

 

 “Take any two FRS (or bubble-pack GMRS) radios from competing manufacturers and set each radio on a different channel with different call tones. Hand the radios to an average person with an instruction book and ask them to set the radios up so they can talk to each other.” One or both people will certainly give up and setting up a radio to communicate during an emergency is too late!

 

Manufacturers have an opportunity to reverse confusion by developing FRS only radios for use in neighborhoods as radios for crime prevention teams or CERT with the following features:

 

  1. FRS only channels so radios can be used license free.
  2. Elimination of the tone-coded squelch option.
    1. Eliminates complicated set up
    2. Eliminates problems associated with model differences between manufacturers
    3. Eliminates interference to GMRS repeaters when operated on FRS eight through fourteen.
    4. Enables persons to quickly and easily talk to each other.
  3. Elimination of the call tone feature. This feature has rarely served a useful purpose. It is most frequently used to interfere with and to annoy others. It makes the radio a toy.
  4. Simple one-button scan function.

 

Why make the changes?

 

 

Most serious GMRS licensees invest in high quality commercial grade two-way radio equipment and have invested a great deal of money in this equipment. Commercial grade radios last longer, are more reliable, and in many cases much simpler to use.